Mau-mauing the Maoist flak-catcher
19 October 2009
One of the first rules of public speaking is, "be careful whom you quote". If you're a reasonably educated human being, therefore, it should be obvious that you don't cite Pol Pot if you're giving a speech about agricultural policy, and you don't look to Adolf Hitler, vehement anti-smoker that he was, for words to back up an address on the evils of tobacco.
Nor should one, if addressing a group of high school students (or anyone else, really), refer to a man whose reign of terror resulted, conservatively, in the deaths of 60 million people as one of your favourite political philosophers - which is just what White House Communications Director Anita Dunn did recently.
Watch the tape - it's pretty damning. Or if you don't feel like wading through the speech, here's the choice bit: "In 1947, when Mao Tse-tung was being challenged within his own party, on his plan to basically take China over, Chiang Kai-shek and the nationalist Chinese held the cities, they had the army, they had the air force, they had everything on their side and people said how can you win, how can you do this, how can you do this against all odds against you, and Mao Tse-tung said 'You fight your war and I'll fight mine.' Think about that for a second, you don't have to accept the definition of how to do things and you don't have to follow other people's choices in the past."
Even if it was a joke, it was not a funny one. Indeed, it sounds more like outright admiration for a man whose perverse brand of anti-intellectual Marxism that was simultaneously brutally centralised yet scarily anarchic gave his countrymen the horrors of the Great Leap Forward, the Cultural Revolution, and a gulag system that exists to this day. (Perhaps this is why Barack Obama was so quick to snub the Dalai Lama?)
Look, forget the Obamas' long-standing friendship with Bill Ayers and Bernadine Dohrn. The fact is, the Obama White House is rapidly becoming a big tent for the sort of cranks who set up card tables on the fringes of growers' markets and pass out hand-xeroxed fliers.
Yes, 9/11 "truther" Van Jones lost his "green jobs" czar role, but that leaves plenty of largely unaccountable individuals like science advisor John Holdren who used to advocate forced abortions and a "planetary regime" to control population, or legal advisor Harold Koh.
Koh, let's not forget, is the high-ranking legal advisor who has spoken out in support of sharia law, discounted the notion of the US Constitution as the supreme law of the land (he prefers global, transnational arrangements), and written the still-confidential advice the Obama administration has used to brand the constitutional removal of Honduras's Chavezista president "a coup".
In this depressing context, it's no wonder Anita Dunn fits right in.
All the more reason for her to be kicked out.
Comments
Eugene Dillenburg
3:42 AM on Tue 20 October 2009
From 1978-1982, I studied Advertising at a small liberal-arts college. My copy writing teacher, a young guy, professional in the field, said it was OK to include a photo of Hitler in an ad featuring famous vegetarians. I argued that associating Hitler to any product or idea made me feel much less favorable toward it, and thus less likely to purchase whatever is being advertised. But he said no, "Hitler is a vegetarian" is the kind of interesting tidbit that would attract readers' attention. He didn't seem overtly radical (the fact that he worked in advertising made him pariah among the school's liberal elite). He was actually pretty down-to-Earth, famous for writing beer and pizza commercials. Hitler was just a way of getting attention.
(He also told me that quoting Mies van der Rohe's dictum "Less is more" was elitist and would turn readers off.)
I do not offer this as a defense of Dunn nor as a critique of academia (nor of advertising), but simply to note that historical ignorance is sadly widespread, even among the educated.
PersonFromPorlock
6:10 AM on Tue 20 October 2009
Fussbudget that I am, I feel a need to point out that dinner guests chez Hitler were invited to 'light 'em up' after the meal. Try THAT with your modern anti-smoker: Hitler at least understood that being a host wasn't all about him.
It's very odd, but the phrase "anti-smoking nazi" is the only one I can think of that actually slanders the real nazis.
RebeccaH
7:07 AM on Tue 20 October 2009
Never mind kicking the thoroughly ignorant Anita Dunn out. Kick the whole rotten regime out, I say.
Worst. President. Ever.
Worst. Congress. Ever.
Worst. Political Class. Ever.
I Call BS
1:32 AM on Wed 21 October 2009
Mao considered himself a philosopher. Anybody who quotes him for anything they wish to promote, other than the need for eternal vigilance against totalitarian, murderous, fascist, phony "populist" regimes, is a dangerously ignorant delusional. An (interim) White House Communications Director who quotes him this way deserves to be scraping the congealed grease out of filth-encrusted drains on hot, humid days, in alleys behind lousy Chinese restaurants in bad parts of town. What an ignorame-ass.
You Missed Kevin Jennings
11:04 AM on Wed 21 October 2009
Let's not forget the "Safe Schools Czar" who's teaching our kids about Harry Hay -- and not so they'll know to call the cops if they see someone like Harry hanging around the schoolyard.
Conservatives may be dour and scolding, but they'd never turn a pedophile into a civil rights icon.
Have your say
Recent Posts
- Book Launch: Financial Fraud and Guerrilla Violence in Missouri's Civil War, 1861-1865
- Ethical supply chains: An executive roundtable
- Jeffrey Schott: Trade policy in the Obama administration and the outlook for Asia- Pacific economic integration
- Race in America, race in Australia: A public forum featuring Glenn Loury, Waleed Aly and Bob Carr
- Workshop on Inequality
- China-US relations: Partners or rivals
- Mark Tushnet: Current issues and controversies in the US
- Gail Fosler: What the financial crisis tells us about ourselves - A US perspective on economic and governance challenges
- Jonathan Greenblatt delivers lecture to undergraduate students
- Peter Katzenstein: Why the clash of civilizations is wrong
- Henry Cisneros on housing and sustainability
- James Hansen: What Australia should do about climate change
- War correspondent Mark Danner in conversation with Geoffrey Garrett
- Launch of the Dow Sustainability Program
- Sustainable supply chains
- David Brady: The Obama Presidency and the outlook for the coming year
- US Ambassador meets students at the US Studies Centre
- US Business Leadership Forum with Rupert Murdoch
- Celebrating the launch of American Review
- One year of Obama: A discussion with James Fallows, Paul Kelly, Robert Hill and Geoffrey Garrett
- James Fallows: One year of Obama
- Obama: One year in the making
- Meeting of the US Studies Centre Council of Advisors
- Costello discusses post-GFC financial reform
- Jim Johnson: How is Obama responding to the financial crisis?
- Jim Johnson seminar with US Studies students
- US Politics in the Pub: The rebirth of the Republican right?
- Dennis Richardson discusses the state of Australia-US relations
- "US in the World" High school lecture
- 2009 National Summit: Dinner
- 2009 National Summit: John Micklethwait Keynote Speech
- 2009 National Summit: Human health and sustainability - What are the challenges for globalisation?
- 2009 National Summit: Expert Sessions 2
- 2009 National Summit: Business solves poverty - The new approach to corporate social responsibility
- 2009 National Summit: Corporate social responsibility - How should business behave in the GFC?
- 2009 National Summit: Climate change and energy security - Looking towards the Copenhagen Conference
- 2009 National Summit: Breakfast
- 2009 National Summit: Public Forum
- 2009 National Summit: Expert Sessions 1
- 2009 National Summit: Labour and human rights - Can we afford them in a global financial crisis?
- 2009 National Summit: Malcolm Turnbull Keynote Speech
- 2009 National Summit: Governing the global economy - Economic nationalism vs. Bretton Woods 2.0
- 2009 National Summit: Obama's America - Globalisation headaches and protectionist impulses
- 2009 National Summit: Peter Garrett Opening Address
- 2009 National Summit: Welcome Address
- 2009 National Summit: Welcome Reception
- 2009 National Summit: Masterclass
- Thomas Mann: The Obama Administration and its Outlook on the Asia Pacific
- Thomas Mann: The First 100 Days of the Obama Administration
- Robert Burgelman: Leading Strategically in a Turbulent Environment
- Robert Thomson: The Obama Administration and the Actions Shaping the Global Financial Crisis
- Barry Jackson: Evaluating the Obama Stimulus Package
- The Great American Recession: What Does It Mean For You?
- Edward Leamer: The Financial Crisis and the Outlook for the US
- Inauguration Watch: Manning Bar
- Inauguration Watch: Breakfast
- Harry Harding: China in the 21st Century and Policy Implications for Australia, the US and the World
- Christmas Function
- fdgdfsg sdf sdfg
- The President-Elect: What Can We Expect?
- David Brady: The US Under the New President
- Election Day Spectacular
- Michael Parks and Simon Jackman: America at the Crossroads
- 'US in the World' High School Lecture
- Foreign Policy of Obama and McCain: Which is Australia's Gain?
- Mike Chinoy: Global Crisis Points - The War on Terror, Loose Nukes and American Foreign Policy
- James Gibbons: Replicating Silicon Valley - Lessons for Australia
- Vice Presidential Debate Screening
- Visit by the Australian Political Exchange Council’s 25th US Delegation
- Derek Shearer: Obama v McCain - Who Will Win, Does it Matter?
- John Howard Dinner
- McCain's Acceptance Speech: Republican National Convention
- New Horizons: Breaking into the US market
- Sydney Uni Live!
- Obama's Acceptance Speech: Democratic National Convention
- Hedley Bull Book Launch: Address by Bob Hawke
- Great White Fleet Centenary Ball
- Dick McCormack: Global Financial Risk and the Role of Central Banks and Regulators
- Jonathan Pollack: US-North Asia Relations
- Jeffrey Sachs Dinner
- ANZASA Conference
- Peter Scher: Will US Trade Policy Change After the 2008 Elections?
- Peter Scher: The Next President's Challenge - Global Trade and the 2008 Elections
- Matt Bai: US Political Journalism - The Next Generation
- Bob Pisano: Positioning Australian Screen Content in the US Marketplace
- Marvin Goodfriend: The Outlook for the US Economy and the State of the Financial Institutions
- American Foreign Policy After Bush: Frank Fukuyama in Conversation with Geoffrey Garrett
- Frank Fukuyama Meets US Studies Students
- Frank Fukuyama: Contemporary Issues Facing America
- Super Tuesday screening at the Manning Bar
- 2007 National Summit: Public Forum
- 2007 National Summit: Networking and Research Forum
- 2007 National Summit: America Then, America Now
- 2007 National Summit: Climate Change or Islamofascism
- 2007 National Summit: Dinner
- 2007 National Summit: How Countries Compete
- 2007 National Summit: Will the Next US Foreign Policy Look Surprisingly Like the Current One?
- 2007 National Opinion Survey: Australian Attitudes Towards the US (Part 2)
- 2007 National Summit: Opening
- 2007 National Summit: Welcome Reception
- Role of Arts and Humanities in Building International Understanding: Harriet Mayor Fulbright
- 2007 National Opinion Survey: Australian Attitudes Towards the US (Part 1)
Archive
- July 2010
- June 2010
- May 2010
- April 2010
- March 2010
- February 2010
- December 2009
- November 2009
- October 2009
- September 2009
- August 2009
- June 2009
- May 2009
- April 2009
- March 2009
- January 2009
- December 2008
- November 2008
- October 2008
- September 2008
- August 2008
- July 2008
- June 2008
- May 2008
- March 2008
- December 2007
- October 2007
Blogs Feed

bigbooner
2:34 AM on Tue 20 October 2009
Never heard referred to as a "philosopher" before. Guess I am going to have to rethink what I call Hitler and Stalin.